New owners Paul and Carter Catalano invite you to try The Ice Cream Smuggler’s 27 homemade ice cream flavors and 4 frozen yogurt varieties. Also included on the menu are sherbets and sorbets as well as sugar-free ice cream. Cones can be served in sugar, cake, waffle, chocolate dipped sugar, chocolate dipped waffle, and chocolate dipped waffle bowls. In addition to cones, the Smuggler serves sundaes, brownie sundaes, banana splits, frappes, malts, ice cream sodas, and freezes made with sherbet or sorbet. Hand packed pints and quarts may also be purchased.
The husband and wife team with their daughter Abbie and son Ben purchased the Smuggler in the spring of 2005. The previous owners and friends of the family Alan and Maggi Tyson passed along the Smuggler’s recipes and trained the Catalano’s in depth in the art of making homemade ice cream, ice cream cakes and fudge bottom ice cream pies.
Our homemade ice cream is delicious because it is made daily in small batches using only the finest ingredients available. As a matter of fact, the ice cream at the Ice Cream Smuggler is still made the same way today as it was in 1979, with a few improvements of course.
The staff here at the Smuggler is always ready to serve you and your table is waiting inside or outside! We are continually being asked if we ship ice cream- at present we do not- so come in and experience the best ice cream on Cape Cod!
